Jeremiah tells PEOPLE the day 1 couple "skipped a lot of steps" as he reveals what the final straw was for him in their relationship: "I really cared about her"

Jeremiah Brown explains why he'll never get back together with Huda Mustafa after being dumped from Love Island USA.

Love Island USA's Jeremiah Brown answered every burning question about his time in the villa — including his messy romance with Huda Mustafa